Past Thrice Illustrious Masters
| 1920 | Maurice E. White |
| 1921 | B. Atmore Dowlin |
| 1922 | Thomas Kingston |
| 1923 | William E. Bauer |
| 1924 | Ambrose B. Umstead |
| 1925 | Lloyd E. Stickler |
| 1926 | Jeremiah O. Siegfried |
| 1927 | John H. O’Neil (MPGM) |
| 1928 | Harry S. Ganser |
| 1929 | Deems W. Hallman |
| 1930 | C. Voorhees Honeyman |
| 1931 | Harry Watson |
| 1932 | John R. Wood |
| 1933 | Howard B. Keyser |
| 1934 | Harry W. Akins |
| 1935 | M. Eugene Seltzer |
| 1936 | Harry S. Custer |
| 1937 | Leon K. Bell |
| 1938 | Leslie H. Fox |
| 1939 | Charles F. Miller |
| 1940 | Samuel R. McHenry |
| 1941 | Howard F. Reichard |
| 1942 | Richard M. Parry |
| 1943 | Irwin D. Hallman |
| 1944 | Arthur C. Wood (MPGM) |
| 1945 | William H. Russell Jr. |
| 1946 | Anthony B. Nugent |
| 1947 | Courtland B. Brinton |
| 1948 | Joseph P. Darlington |
| 1949 | Maurice T. White |
| 1950 | Robert S. Hanson |
| 1951 | Walter S. Cassel |
| 1952 | Claude B. Nyce |
| 1953 | Joseph S. Moser |
| 1954 | Frank M. Stever |
| 1955 | Russell H. Zeigler |
| 1956 | Robert B. Wood |
| 1957 | Arthur P. Bomkemper |
| 1958 | Franklyn W. Wagner |
| 1959 | Albert A. Glover |
| 1960 | Charles E. Kepder |
| 1961 | William S. Bloomer |
| 1962 | David J. Godschall |
| 1963 | Harold W. Groff |
| 1964 | Charles G. Shute |
| 1965 | James L. Wall |
| 1966 | Earl L. Kunkle |
| 1967 | John L. Krupp |
| 1968 | Ralph H. Ott |
| 1969 | George Wollrath |
| 1970 | William E. Neeld |
| 1971 | Charles E. Martin |
| 1972 | J. Leonard Jamison |
| 1973 | Haroid H. Dennison |
| 1974 | Gerald H. Woerner |
| 1975 | Russell J. Corsner |
| 1976 | William J. McCauley |
| 1977 | Richard L. Evans Jr. |
| 1978 | Joseph P. Toal |
| 1979 | George S. Larue |
| 1980 | Ferman O. Stevenson |
| 1981 | George E. Miller Jr. |
| 1982 | Carl A. Sandberg |
| 1983 | William E. Yoder |
| 1984 | Charles H. Wernersbach |
| 1985 | Winton E. Hewitt |
| 1986 | H. Edward Schanbacker Jr. |
| 1987 | Sydney S. Painter Jr. |
| 1988 | Thomas R. Eynon |
| 1989 | Ralph C. Berg |
| 1990 | Henry E. Deebel |
| 1991 | Richard D. Schwager |
| 1992 | Matthew D. Dupee |
| 1993 | George Nakonetschny |
| 1994 | Robert J. Cathers |
| 1995 | David C. Nace |
| 1996 | Hillborn Darlington Jr. |
| 1997 | Edward R. Vogel |
| 1998 | Jerry J. Hamilton |
| 1999 | W. Henry Michener |
| 2000 | Michael F. Imperial |
| 2001 | Thomas M. Riddington |
| 2002 | Robert D. Fighera Jr. |
| 2003 | Joseph E. McQuillen JR. |
| 2004 | Douglas M. Rowe |
| 2005 | Thomas W. Aiken |
| 2006 | Irvin Miller Jr. |
| 2007 | Robert W. Bunch Jr. |
| 2008 | Jonathan H. Lander |
| 2009 | Emery J. Kohut |
| 2010 | J. Ronald Dotsey |
| 2011 | Kent A. Baird |
| 2011 | Kenneth G. Kriebel |
| 2012 | Austin R. Hodge |
| 2013 | Rodney A. Gilbert |
| 2014 | Gary L. Schuyler |
| 2015 | George Chiaverini |
| 2016 | Kirk E. Muller |
| 2017 | Scott A. Wolfertz |
| 2018 | Gary L. Schuyler |
| 2019 | G. Windsor Tracy, Jr. |
| 2020 | Edward G. Davis, Jr. |
| 2021 | Stephen E. Keib |
| 2022 | Yasser A. Al-Khatib |